Comparison of 34 corpora (conferences + journals)

GENERAL COUNTING	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
Time span in years	37	10	12	18	39	35	50	19	30	32	20	30	26	11	19	29	13	11	17	21	23	29	8	16	20	5	15	34	3	10	19	41	6	24	51	51
#Venues	37	10	12	6	39	35	21	18	29	14	20	19	26	6	7	28	5	11	9	7	23	15	5	11	19	3	8	34	3	10	19	41	3	24	577
Total of #docs	4264	82	262	278	927	751	3812	842	762	900	2020	2219	9818	1188	227	18363	506	308	4552	656	232	795	149	1186	1039	363	949	593	92	177	1019	6604	105	1847	67887
% of #docs wrt the other corpora	6.3	0.1	0.4	0.4	1.4	1.1	5.6	1.2	1.1	1.3	3.0	3.3	14.5	1.7	0.3	27.0	0.7	0.5	6.7	1.0	0.3	1.2	0.2	1.7	1.5	0.5	1.4	0.9	0.1	0.3	1.5	9.7	0.2	2.7	100	100
#Papers	4264	82	262	278	927	751	3812	842	762	900	2020	2219	9818	1188	227	18363	506	308	4552	656	232	795	149	1186	1039	363	949	593	92	177	1019	6604	105	1847	64953	64953
Avg of #docs per venue	115	8	22	46	24	21	182	47	26	64	101	117	378	198	32	656	101	28	506	94	10	53	30	108	55	121	119	17	31	18	54	161	35	77	118	118
#Different Authors	5079	239	318	571	1144	1011	5123	1461	1578	1537	3040	2871	11523	2370	368	16527	772	870	7282	1114	308	1365	215	1971	1521	698	1820	1411	244	381	1171	7471	156	3157	48854	48854
#Signatures	10904	266	606	679	1400	1506	9111	2352	2257	2015	5939	6050	29903	3713	588	55198	1547	1051	15340	1616	410	2095	485	3301	2313	915	3089	1697	288	471	2597	15454	246	6735
#Signatures per doc	2.557	3.244	2.313	2.442	1.510	2.005	2.390	2.793	2.962	2.239	2.940	2.726	3.046	3.125	2.590	3.006	3.057	3.412	3.370	2.463	1.767	2.635	3.255	2.783	2.226	2.521	3.255	2.862	3.130	2.661	2.549	2.340	2.343	3.646
Ratio of #signatures per author	2.147	1.113	1.906	1.189	1.224	1.490	1.778	1.610	1.430	1.311	1.954	2.107	2.595	1.567	1.598	3.340	2.004	1.208	2.107	1.451	1.331	1.535	2.256	1.675	1.521	1.311	1.697	1.203	1.180	1.236	2.218	2.069	1.577	2.133
#docs of the most prolix author	42	3	24	5	7	11	49	23	18	8	35	43	91	19	15	206	18	7	48	15	15	18	10	22	39	10	23	8	3	5	26	53	7	45	206
Max of authors for a doc	15	10	6	11	8	11	14	14	16	15	11	19	27	15	9	29	15	17	44	15	9	19	10	13	9	9	18	14	21	8	17	24	10	19
Ratio of #signatures/#authors (i.e. productivity)	2.147	1.113	1.906	1.189	1.224	1.490	1.778	1.610	1.430	1.311	1.954	2.107	2.595	1.567	1.598	3.340	2.004	1.208	2.107	1.451	1.331	1.535	2.256	1.675	1.521	1.311	1.697	1.203	1.180	1.236	2.218	2.069	1.577	2.133
Ratio of #docs/#authors (i.e. variety)	0.840	0.343	0.824	0.487	0.810	0.743	0.744	0.576	0.483	0.586	0.664	0.773	0.852	0.501	0.617	1.111	0.655	0.354	0.625	0.589	0.753	0.582	0.693	0.602	0.683	0.520	0.521	0.420	0.377	0.465	0.870	0.884	0.673	0.585
#docs with accessible reference section	3903	82	237	190	534	689	2866	762	523	794	1964	1848	7856	1175	179	17606	407	302	4419	567	117	653	102	1148	1013	357	935	419	92	143	846	6062	59	1617
% of docs with accessible reference section	91.5	100.0	90.5	68.3	57.6	91.7	75.2	90.5	68.6	88.2	97.2	83.3	80.0	98.9	78.9	95.9	80.4	98.1	97.1	86.4	50.4	82.1	68.5	96.8	97.5	98.3	98.5	70.7	100.0	80.8	83.0	91.8	56.2	87.5
CORPUS SUBSETS	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
belongs to ACL Anthology	yes	no	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	no	yes	no	yes	no	no	no	yes	yes	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	no	yes	no	yes	no	26723
deals mainly with NLP	yes	no	yes	yes	yes	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	no	no	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	yes	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	yes	30927
deals mainly with Speech	no	yes	no	no	no	no	no	no	yes	no	no	no	yes	no	no	yes	yes	yes	yes	yes	no	yes	no	no	no	no	no	yes	no	no	no	yes	no	no	43039
deals mainly with Information Retrieval	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	yes	no	yes	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	no	yes	yes	2333
AUTHOR GENRE	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of male authors (2 cases: male given name or epicene known member gender)	3020	158	193	380	766	685	2954	925	1019	1028	1780	1788	4836	1239	226	9320	402	520	4334	674	185	787	129	1256	700	424	1075	868	167	239	700	2473	101	1176
# of female authors (2 cases: female given name or epicene known member gender)	771	52	62	103	221	202	813	203	204	291	409	474	644	306	93	2408	238	217	1950	254	67	247	40	322	196	162	357	203	37	131	375	274	41	253
# of unknown gender authors (3 cases: unknown given name, epicene unknown member gender or one letter given name)	1288	29	63	88	157	124	1356	333	355	218	851	609	6043	825	49	4799	132	133	998	186	56	331	46	393	625	112	388	340	40	11	96	4724	14	1728
# unknown given name (subcase#1 of unknown gender case)	971	21	48	43	100	82	942	254	239	154	649	415	3200	625	39	3107	66	113	834	153	25	231	24	293	451	101	311	221	28	8	78	2378	7	897
# of epicene unknown member gender (subcase#2 of unknown gender case)	293	7	13	27	13	31	293	75	77	35	195	126	589	192	9	946	7	17	121	13	6	74	9	95	171	11	73	69	12	3	17	300	5	154
# of authors with a one letter given name (subcase#3 of unknown gender case)	24	1	2	18	44	11	121	4	39	29	7	68	2254	8	1	746	59	3	43	20	25	26	13	5	3	0	4	50	0	0	1	2046	2	677

# of male given names	1313	138	130	261	360	409	1343	600	632	622	956	879	1766	786	180	2465	214	389	1631	417	114	525	88	708	462	335	679	538	134	154	333	1196	68	649	3821
# of female given names	469	50	54	87	161	152	498	168	167	228	297	306	400	247	81	1005	143	176	870	194	54	192	37	235	149	140	267	164	35	105	231	199	36	204	1739
# of epicene given names	124	9	12	24	14	27	139	61	60	37	97	80	161	103	11	218	6	18	110	16	3	55	8	61	92	14	59	51	14	3	15	116	5	74	281

% of one letter given name	0.5	0.4	0.6	3.2	3.8	1.1	2.4	0.3	2.5	1.9	0.2	2.4	19.6	0.3	0.3	4.5	7.6	0.3	0.6	1.8	8.1	1.9	6.0	0.3	0.2	0.0	0.2	3.5	0.0	0.0	0.1	27.4	1.3	21.4

Extrapolated percentage of male authors	79.7	75.2	75.7	78.7	77.6	77.2	78.4	82.0	83.3	77.9	81.3	79.0	88.2	80.2	70.8	79.5	62.8	70.6	69.0	72.6	73.4	76.1	76.3	79.6	78.1	72.4	75.1	81.0	81.9	64.6	65.1	90.0	71.1	82.3
Extrapolated percentage of female authors	20.3	24.8	24.3	21.3	22.4	22.8	21.6	18.0	16.7	22.1	18.7	21.0	11.8	19.8	29.2	20.5	37.2	29.4	31.0	27.4	26.6	23.9	23.7	20.4	21.9	27.6	24.9	19.0	18.1	35.4	34.9	10.0	28.9	17.7
AUTHOR RENEWAL	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of new authors	7313	245	360	533	1297	1338	6314	1756	1934	1678	4123	3691	16245	2333	355	25870	635	928	8065	1154	359	1561	173	2322	1777	494	1924	1577	141	375	1725	10473	116	3663
% of new authors	79.0	98.4	76.8	91.3	97.2	92.9	80.1	83.6	92.2	90.9	81.0	76.6	70.5	85.6	80.1	65.8	65.7	95.9	70.6	83.0	95.5	85.5	61.1	82.6	87.5	87.3	78.1	96.9	86.0	93.5	75.4	80.3	77.9	61.8
Average of annual percentage of new authors	82.8	98.3	76.3	90.8	97.0	93.1	81.6	81.3	92.4	90.4	83.9	74.2	70.6	84.2	80.8	67.2	65.5	96.1	71.4	83.2	94.1	85.6	61.6	82.7	86.4	87.2	78.2	96.9	85.4	93.5	77.1	81.1	77.6	60.9
% of new authors minus two years	82.4	99.1	80.0	91.5	96.7	94.4	79.6	89.7	92.4	89.8	83.9	77.2	75.1	86.4	78.6	67.9	62.3	95.9	70.6	80.8	94.8	85.5	71.2	84.6	91.1	87.3	85.9	97.5	84.2	94.7	77.6	83.0	75.4	76.0

# of completly new authors	5047	235	286	507	1137	993	5091	1428	1561	1480	3016	2827	10994	2051	314	16046	571	831	6777	1066	301	1337	162	1889	1468	484	1723	1401	136	328	1164	7325	113	3085
% of completly new authors	54.5	94.4	61.0	86.8	85.2	68.9	64.6	68.0	74.4	80.2	59.3	58.7	47.7	75.3	70.9	40.8	59.1	85.8	59.3	76.6	80.1	73.2	57.2	67.2	72.3	85.5	70.0	86.1	82.9	81.8	50.9	56.2	75.8	52.1

Name of last year	2015	2013	2014	2000	2004	2014	2014	2015	2015	2014	2015	2015	2015	2015	2014	2015	2014	2015	2014	2015	2010	2015	1998	2015	2014	2013	2015	2015	2015	2015	2015	2015	1998	2015
Last year percentage of new authors	75.5	100.0	81.0	79.6	95.8	89.6	75.4	82.3	89.1	87.8	78.5	84.2	77.7	92.0	81.9	65.0	59.4	89.2	70.7	81.2	100.0	90.1	82.4	84.2	94.9	84.4	77.4	93.9	84.2	92.9	73.9	81.1	75.4	75.5
Last year percentage of completly new authors	51.9	96.2	66.7	70.9	77.1	63.6	56.0	62.2	76.0	72.3	59.5	64.9	60.2	75.8	67.5	40.0	48.1	71.2	56.1	67.5	75.0	65.3	75.0	67.6	75.0	80.7	63.3	81.1	71.1	50.0	40.8	56.2	70.8	61.7
COLLABORATION NETWORK	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of effective edges	10533	427	457	805	740	1241	8812	2545	3309	2068	6370	7068	31992	4581	624	52601	1938	2004	24794	1741	333	2631	590	3797	2064	914	4155	2255	555	586	2487	12867	360	9790
# of potential edges	12895581	28441	50403	162735	653796	510555	13120003	1066530	1244253	1180416	4619280	4119885	66384003	2807265	67528	136562601	297606	378015	26510121	619941	47278	930930	23005	1941435	1155960	243253	1655290	994755	29646	72390	685035	27904185	12090	4981746
Density	0.000817	0.015014	0.009067	0.004947	0.001132	0.002431	0.000672	0.002386	0.002659	0.001752	0.001379	0.001716	0.000482	0.001632	0.009241	0.000385	0.006512	0.005301	0.000935	0.002808	0.007043	0.002826	0.025647	0.001956	0.001786	0.003757	0.002510	0.002267	0.018721	0.008095	0.003630	0.000461	0.029777	0.001965
Max Degree	76	15	29	13	16	15	65	30	34	20	60	54	119	46	30	201	37	25	161	36	11	32	16	35	47	13	45	14	27	11	33	73	23	69
Mean Degree	4.148	3.573	2.874	2.820	1.294	2.455	3.440	3.484	4.194	2.691	4.191	4.924	5.553	3.866	3.391	6.365	5.021	4.607	6.810	3.126	2.162	3.855	5.488	3.853	2.714	2.619	4.566	3.196	4.549	3.076	4.248	3.445	4.615	6.202
Average Clustering Coefficient	0.603	0.742	0.551	0.617	0.286	0.482	0.572	0.652	0.692	0.558	0.667	0.651	0.656	0.708	0.645	0.663	0.658	0.775	0.731	0.626	0.459	0.682	0.761	0.649	0.565	0.617	0.746	0.702	0.698	0.642	0.620	0.534	0.619	0.792
Diameter of the corpus graph	15	3	10	8	5	14	20	16	24	18	17	17	19	23	10	15	13	12	15	11	4	18	9	15	12	6	14	7	5	7	13	24	5	15
#Pairs with this distance	36	11	9	1	21	15	3	20	22	6	4	12	18	1	10	9	65	5	140	12	85	11	9	36	24	40	24	4	7	5	24	45	140	2

#connected components	745	62	63	190	698	313	1014	252	274	489	272	294	993	319	76	981	82	176	477	314	139	298	33	248	456	215	279	369	54	107	142	1307	38	267
Size of the largest connected component	3431	17	157	25	23	112	2711	560	539	116	2199	2058	8420	1163	162	14144	600	148	5887	108	27	403	103	1161	138	29	714	32	38	37	830	4223	39	2049
Diameter of the largest connected component	15	3	10	8	4	14	20	16	24	18	17	17	19	23	10	15	13	12	15	9	4	18	9	15	12	6	14	4	5	7	13	24	5	15
% of authors in the largest connected component	67.553	7.113	49.371	4.378	2.010	11.078	52.918	38.330	34.157	7.547	72.336	71.682	73.071	49.072	44.022	85.581	77.720	17.011	80.843	9.695	8.766	29.524	47.907	58.904	9.073	4.155	39.231	2.268	15.574	9.711	70.880	56.525	25.000	64.903
Average path length of the largest connected component	5.962	1.625	4.556	3.200	1.909	6.472	7.763	6.606	9.041	7.308	6.635	5.920	5.663	7.384	4.199	5.445	5.335	5.152	5.500	3.634	2.650	6.932	3.901	6.292	4.597	3.244	5.424	2.690	2.065	3.225	5.371	7.770	2.807	5.845
Average path length of the connected components of size>1	1.097	1.092	1.243	1.106	1.069	1.255	1.152	1.191	1.158	1.191	1.128	1.127	1.120	1.162	1.212	1.111	1.183	1.152	1.111	1.127	1.084	1.172	1.222	1.181	1.210	1.148	1.138	1.143	1.168	1.172	1.159	1.127	1.271	1.146
Weighted average path length of the connected components of size>1	4.671	1.189	3.041	1.303	1.186	2.539	5.069	3.528	4.190	1.979	5.188	4.699	4.516	4.364	2.698	4.926	4.580	1.985	4.750	1.755	1.361	3.475	2.552	4.375	2.006	1.384	2.974	1.450	1.416	1.531	4.310	5.184	1.876	4.299

Size of the largest Clique	15	10	6	11	8	11	14	14	16	15	11	19	27	15	9	29	15	17	44	12	9	10	10	13	9	9	18	14	21	8	17	24	10	19
CITING AUTHOR CITATION NETWORK	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of citing authors to the given corpus	3769	53	62	131	240	802	2394	834	592	374	2288	1702	6198	758	104	10441	99	241	4239	109	19	558	76	1082	158	79	1259	261	32	75	484	5917	41	2017
% of citing authors to the given corpus	74.2	22.2	19.5	22.9	21.0	79.3	46.7	57.1	37.5	24.3	75.3	59.3	53.8	32.0	28.3	63.2	12.8	27.7	58.2	9.8	6.2	40.9	35.3	54.9	10.4	11.3	69.2	18.5	13.1	19.7	41.3	79.2	26.3	63.9
# of effective edges	65361	200	242	462	832	7438	15649	9629	3239	1171	32375	17670	101009	3835	482	187362	441	1322	45968	606	33	2945	373	8142	600	252	16460	1243	123	269	3132	82582	179	30273
# of potential edges	25796241	57121	101124	326041	1308736	1022121	26245129	2134521	2490084	2362369	9241600	8242641	132779529	5616900	135424	273141729	595984	756900	53027524	1240996	94864	1863225	46225	3884841	2313441	487204	3312400	1990921	59536	145161	1371241	55815841	24336	9966649
Density	0.002534	0.003501	0.002393	0.001417	0.000636	0.007277	0.000596	0.004511	0.001301	0.000496	0.003503	0.002144	0.000761	0.000683	0.003559	0.000686	0.000740	0.001747	0.000867	0.000488	0.000348	0.001581	0.008069	0.002096	0.000259	0.000517	0.004969	0.000624	0.002066	0.001853	0.002284	0.001480	0.007355	0.003037
Max Degree	496	22	28	20	28	141	268	184	108	60	372	334	647	192	30	878	53	42	202	25	4	130	23	290	42	21	166	74	37	28	97	529	38	286
Mean Degree	27.900	6.414	2.340	2.543	1.124	17.955	12.463	19.220	9.397	7.485	31.957	20.859	18.090	16.156	4.122	21.113	3.284	7.103	12.813	1.606	0.107	9.578	3.023	19.689	2.078	2.924	15.791	5.554	10.598	4.963	6.077	18.430	3.397	10.604
Diameter	8	9	6	16	9	10	11	8	9	10	8	8	9	8	7	11	10	9	10	11	2	11	8	7	15	12	8	12	6	10	9	12	6	8
#Pairs with this distance	156	69	88	1	20	2	5	2	4	120	3	15	122	30	53	2	3	402	301	16	4	5	6	107	22	8	31	12	87	3	5	9	81	35

# of citing authors to all corpora	4535	239	266	356	366	916	3684	1353	1064	1269	2952	2631	8088	2268	254	12901	432	835	6301	751	21	1097	140	1880	1053	656	1737	902	244	276	859	6257	94	2270
% of citing authors to all corpora	89.3	100.0	83.6	62.3	32.0	90.6	71.9	92.6	67.4	82.6	97.1	91.6	70.2	95.7	69.0	78.1	56.0	96.0	86.5	67.4	6.8	80.4	65.1	95.4	69.2	94.0	95.4	63.9	100.0	72.4	73.4	83.8	60.3	71.9
# of effective edges	1344344	68636	46678	21027	14008	265955	737734	390030	182633	218559	1042641	640815	1095110	598996	29954	1877626	40337	161464	900048	71385	74	216263	8661	498559	129562	105349	357769	107178	96073	62024	163336	805543	6504	147946
# of potential edges	248129466	11676106	15535572	27895634	55888976	49391394	250279042	71375694	77091612	75088598	148516160	140259834	562944642	115783980	17978272	807410058	37715288	42502980	355754828	54423356	15047032	66685710	10503610	96291234	74306934	34100092	88914280	68932994	11920376	18613374	57208034	364988234	7621224	154232078
Density	0.052114	1.201590	0.461592	0.064492	0.010703	0.260199	0.028109	0.182725	0.073344	0.092517	0.112820	0.077744	0.008248	0.106642	0.221187	0.006874	0.067681	0.213323	0.016973	0.057522	0.000780	0.116069	0.187366	0.128334	0.056004	0.216232	0.108009	0.053833	1.613696	0.427277	0.119115	0.014432	0.267258	0.014844
Max Degree	639	154	281	39	44	295	436	325	265	159	552	519	795	421	88	1077	164	155	268	126	4	274	41	490	167	162	256	270	159	250	343	1042	38	291
Mean Degree	35.497	40.954	20.340	5.632	2.187	35.789	19.045	34.089	22.113	18.498	45.993	29.968	21.351	33.671	11.299	24.598	9.777	27.879	19.705	10.220	0.120	20.431	6.060	33.335	11.594	19.865	26.303	16.819	51.627	24.087	20.078	25.918	5.974	11.913
CITED AUTHOR CITATION NETWORK	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of cited authors from the given corpus	2720	41	70	108	291	653	1759	621	473	315	1574	1199	5131	537	75	8545	91	216	3197	110	17	431	65	661	167	74	844	262	33	62	418	4599	71	1764
% of cited authors from the given corpus	53.6	17.2	22.0	18.9	25.4	64.6	34.3	42.5	30.0	20.5	51.8	41.8	44.5	22.7	20.4	51.7	11.8	24.8	43.9	9.9	5.5	31.6	30.2	33.5	11.0	10.6	46.4	18.6	13.5	16.3	35.7	61.6	45.5	55.9
# of effective edges	65361	200	242	462	832	7438	15649	9629	3239	1171	32375	17670	101009	3835	482	187362	441	1322	45968	606	33	2945	373	8142	600	252	16460	1243	123	269	3132	82582	179	30273
# of potential edges	25796241	57121	101124	326041	1308736	1022121	26245129	2134521	2490084	2362369	9241600	8242641	132779529	5616900	135424	273141729	595984	756900	53027524	1240996	94864	1863225	46225	3884841	2313441	487204	3312400	1990921	59536	145161	1371241	55815841	24336	9966649
Density	0.002534	0.003501	0.002393	0.001417	0.000636	0.007277	0.000596	0.004511	0.001301	0.000496	0.003503	0.002144	0.000761	0.000683	0.003559	0.000686	0.000740	0.001747	0.000867	0.000488	0.000348	0.001581	0.008069	0.002096	0.000259	0.000517	0.004969	0.000624	0.002066	0.001853	0.002284	0.001480	0.007355	0.003037
Max Degree	1203	46	48	60	43	208	567	437	166	191	1127	537	998	636	49	1506	94	114	553	40	3	453	33	478	100	63	458	113	124	44	123	580	31	584
Mean Degree	27.900	6.414	2.340	2.543	1.124	17.955	12.463	19.220	9.397	7.485	31.957	20.859	18.090	16.156	4.122	21.113	3.284	7.103	12.813	1.606	0.107	9.578	3.023	19.689	2.078	2.924	15.791	5.554	10.598	4.963	6.077	18.430	3.397	10.604
Diameter	8	9	6	16	9	10	11	8	9	10	8	8	9	8	7	11	10	9	10	11	2	11	8	7	15	12	8	12	6	10	9	12	6	8
#Pairs with this distance	156	69	88	1	20	2	5	2	4	120	3	15	122	30	53	2	3	402	301	16	4	5	6	107	22	8	31	12	87	3	5	9	81	35

# of cited authors from all corpora	4381	219	219	479	481	935	3983	1355	1404	1354	2606	2648	8117	1884	281	11114	440	741	5410	580	25	1007	166	1817	735	533	1442	1134	224	329	815	5686	126	2195
% of cited authors from all corpora	86.3	91.6	68.9	83.9	42.0	92.5	77.7	92.7	89.0	88.1	85.7	92.2	70.4	79.5	76.4	67.2	57.0	85.2	74.3	52.1	8.1	73.8	77.2	92.2	48.3	76.4	79.2	80.4	91.8	86.4	69.6	76.1	80.8	69.5
# of effective edges	1011861	103957	33554	139518	64350	457836	781971	491204	465883	422270	789792	926383	993291	515856	52750	1146259	56754	172487	702693	55552	527	256614	45631	712185	103554	80875	302315	273320	135984	54078	73197	730636	44823	254861
# of potential edges	248129466	11676106	15535572	27895634	55888976	49391394	250279042	71375694	77091612	75088598	148516160	140259834	562944642	115783980	17978272	807410058	37715288	42502980	355754828	54423356	15047032	66685710	10503610	96291234	74306934	34100092	88914280	68932994	11920376	18613374	57208034	364988234	7621224	154232078
Density	0.004078	0.008903	0.002160	0.005001	0.001151	0.009270	0.003124	0.006882	0.006043	0.005624	0.005318	0.006605	0.001764	0.004455	0.002934	0.001420	0.001505	0.004058	0.001975	0.001021	0.000035	0.003848	0.004344	0.007396	0.001394	0.002372	0.003400	0.003965	0.011408	0.002905	0.001279	0.002002	0.005881	0.001652
Max Degree	2277	174	108	653	177	2661	893	769	1212	372	1655	1556	1411	488	84	2720	29	444	781	83	3	910	264	1450	64	58	559	406	146	67	82	1539	1109	967
Mean Degree	45.470	15.812	4.865	17.646	2.975	76.327	18.616	35.170	25.698	15.702	39.561	45.807	23.780	12.039	6.921	19.816	1.513	14.590	14.907	2.382	0.127	8.637	19.428	39.042	1.876	3.928	17.082	13.144	17.570	5.307	5.119	24.808	15.686	13.688
CITING/CITED AUTHOR CITATION NETWORK	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
#strongly connected components	1913	108	237	475	1081	240	2977	521	893	904	944	1071	6362	1117	260	8102	595	464	3580	979	308	813	176	716	1302	545	849	970	87	224	740	3112	111	1778
Size of the largest strongly connected component	3139	110	74	52	20	751	2100	933	663	598	2082	1783	5097	1228	100	8322	148	361	3627	66	1	533	26	1243	170	118	936	378	150	128	415	4206	29	1323
% of authors in the largest strongly connected component	61.804	46.025	23.270	9.107	1.748	74.283	40.992	63.860	42.015	38.907	68.487	62.104	44.233	51.814	27.174	50.354	19.171	41.494	49.808	5.925	0.325	39.048	12.093	63.064	11.177	16.905	51.429	26.790	61.475	33.596	35.440	56.298	18.590	41.907
Average path length of the largest connected component	2.914	3.662	2.941	5.466	3.195	3.118	3.417	2.815	3.386	3.631	2.731	2.964	3.153	3.038	2.825	3.205	3.360	3.906	3.646	3.886	0.000	3.466	2.588	2.877	4.862	4.725	3.018	3.964	2.637	3.572	3.206	3.556	3.216	3.299
Average path length of the strongly connected components of size>1	1.182	1.189	1.390	1.274	1.176	1.163	1.072	1.227	1.133	1.136	1.160	1.151	1.046	1.110	1.228	1.055	1.281	1.119	1.100	1.163	0.000	1.176	1.176	1.171	1.182	1.241	1.140	1.114	1.484	1.335	1.204	1.043	1.350	1.115
Weighted average path length of the strongly connected components of size>1	2.889	3.010	2.674	3.058	1.651	3.029	3.327	2.786	3.251	3.401	2.711	2.932	3.106	2.966	2.573	3.162	2.871	3.430	3.562	2.202	0.000	3.322	1.860	2.843	3.659	3.577	2.909	3.370	2.535	3.007	3.070	3.419	2.271	3.169

#strongly connected components with symetric links	3254	148	274	502	1096	593	3871	909	1146	1188	1832	1833	8314	1629	297	11252	647	595	4798	1011	308	1016	183	1279	1378	601	1180	1120	152	283	902	4955	119	2154
Size of the largest strongly connected component with symetric links	51	10	6	6	8	10	32	19	15	7	25	17	62	30	9	102	12	13	43	14	1	19	7	14	10	6	19	10	11	7	18	37	12	24
% of authors in the largest strongly connected component with symetric links	1.004	4.184	1.887	1.051	0.699	0.989	0.625	1.300	0.951	0.455	0.822	0.592	0.538	1.266	2.446	0.617	1.554	1.494	0.590	1.257	0.325	1.392	3.256	0.710	0.657	0.860	1.044	0.709	4.508	1.837	1.537	0.495	7.692	0.760
Average path length of the largest connected component with symetric links	2.174	1.089	4.000	1.667	4.446	1.000	2.297	1.433	4.971	2.357	1.750	1.640	1.902	2.074	1.194	2.129	1.485	1.974	2.364	1.659	0.000	1.000	1.071	1.802	1.333	1.600	1.523	1.700	1.373	1.452	1.873	1.409	3.614	2.373
Average path length of the strongly connected components with symetric links and size>1	1.876	1.257	1.465	1.692	1.423	1.428	2.014	1.708	1.569	1.927	1.728	1.742	1.828	1.866	1.597	1.830	1.535	1.616	1.939	1.310	0.000	2.050	1.203	1.721	1.749	1.549	1.879	1.489	1.269	1.196	1.659	1.814	1.564	2.001
Weighted average path length of the strongly connected components with symetric links and size>1	1.865	1.251	1.521	1.862	1.615	1.397	2.051	1.695	1.628	1.912	1.725	1.738	1.829	1.859	1.564	1.839	1.630	1.644	1.948	1.378	0.000	2.045	1.287	1.713	1.798	1.498	1.873	1.498	1.278	1.183	1.705	1.747	2.005	2.000
CITING DOC CITATION NETWORK	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of citing docs to the given corpus	2954	13	49	55	172	522	1400	439	263	186	1458	1079	5007	296	52	10151	36	79	2236	56	14	267	32	593	94	36	604	94	14	33	356	4747	24	1062
% of citing docs to the given corpus	69.3	15.9	18.7	19.8	18.6	69.5	36.7	52.1	34.5	20.7	72.2	48.6	51.0	24.9	22.9	55.3	7.1	25.6	49.1	8.5	6.0	33.6	21.5	50.0	9.0	9.9	63.6	15.9	15.2	18.6	34.9	71.9	22.9	57.5
# of effective edges	10617	14	64	76	375	1618	2475	1029	467	232	4342	2414	11805	383	66	24350	42	114	4157	74	17	406	61	1129	115	40	1483	141	18	37	547	17194	59	2906
# of potential edges	18177432	6642	68382	77006	858402	563250	14527532	708122	579882	809100	4078380	4921742	96383306	1410156	51302	337181406	255530	94556	20716152	429680	53592	631230	22052	1405410	1078482	131406	899652	351056	8372	31152	1037342	43606212	10920	3409562
Density	0.000584	0.002108	0.000936	0.000987	0.000437	0.002873	0.000170	0.001453	0.000805	0.000287	0.001065	0.000490	0.000122	0.000272	0.001286	0.000072	0.000164	0.001206	0.000201	0.000172	0.000317	0.000643	0.002766	0.000803	0.000107	0.000304	0.001648	0.000402	0.002150	0.001188	0.000527	0.000394	0.005403	0.000852
Max Degree	23	2	3	5	21	13	10	23	9	4	23	11	24	5	3	17	2	7	19	4	3	8	7	7	7	3	13	7	3	2	10	54	8	33
Mean Degree	2.490	0.171	0.244	0.273	0.405	2.154	0.649	1.222	0.613	0.258	2.150	1.088	1.202	0.322	0.291	1.326	0.083	0.370	0.913	0.113	0.073	0.511	0.409	0.952	0.111	0.110	1.563	0.238	0.196	0.209	0.537	2.604	0.562	1.573
Diameter	16	2	3	2	8	10	8	8	7	5	12	11	19	3	4	20	2	3	11	4	2	5	4	7	3	1	9	3	1	2	5	14	3	14
#Pairs with this distance	2	1	1	22	1	8	1	2	1	1	5	7	2	12	10	2	5	2	1	3	1	3	2	2	1	40	36	2	18	3	11	6	4	2

# of citing docs to all corpora	3608	82	217	158	237	619	2366	741	492	700	1935	1753	6830	1128	148	13425	228	287	3770	412	15	560	67	1120	584	332	890	352	92	134	751	4967	44	1208
% of citing docs to all corpora	84.6	100.0	82.8	56.8	25.6	82.4	62.1	88.0	64.6	77.8	95.8	79.0	69.6	94.9	65.2	73.1	45.1	93.2	82.8	62.8	6.5	70.4	45.0	94.4	56.2	91.5	93.8	59.4	100.0	75.7	73.7	75.2	41.9	65.4
# of effective edges	3608	82	217	158	237	619	2366	741	492	700	1935	1753	6830	1128	148	13425	228	287	3770	412	15	560	67	1120	584	332	890	352	92	134	751	4967	44	1208
# of potential edges	276955328	5326064	17017424	18056656	60210504	48778952	247597024	54689584	49493424	58456800	131203040	144128488	637698736	77162976	14744104	1192713576	32865712	20005216	295661504	42608512	15068864	51636840	9677848	77033072	67485128	23577576	61639448	38516536	5975584	11496504	66186088	428943008	6819960	119966344
Density	0.000013	0.000015	0.000013	0.000009	0.000004	0.000013	0.000010	0.000014	0.000010	0.000012	0.000015	0.000012	0.000011	0.000015	0.000010	0.000011	0.000007	0.000014	0.000013	0.000010	0.000001	0.000011	0.000007	0.000015	0.000009	0.000014	0.000014	0.000009	0.000015	0.000012	0.000011	0.000012	0.000006	0.000010
Max Degree	86	39	23	17	24	88	47	40	43	34	48	41	39	44	18	42	18	38	32	16	3	39	14	41	35	25	29	114	45	36	28	188	9	36
Mean Degree	7.532	15.793	4.802	2.288	0.836	10.736	4.360	9.261	6.622	5.636	11.323	6.248	3.584	9.046	3.048	3.323	1.607	8.756	3.704	2.444	0.078	5.038	1.295	8.554	2.583	5.873	6.033	5.408	18.696	7.621	4.004	5.242	1.524	2.286
CITED DOC CITATION NETWORK	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of cited docs from the given corpus	2181	11	46	46	233	431	1075	335	223	161	1046	794	3981	227	41	7996	35	72	1640	49	13	197	40	389	90	32	395	103	12	26	281	3685	30	922
% of cited docs from the given corpus	51.1	13.4	17.6	16.5	25.1	57.4	28.2	39.8	29.3	17.9	51.8	35.8	40.5	19.1	18.1	43.5	6.9	23.4	36.0	7.5	5.6	24.8	26.8	32.8	8.7	8.8	41.6	17.4	13.0	14.7	27.6	55.8	28.6	49.9
# of effective edges	10617	14	64	76	375	1618	2475	1029	467	232	4342	2414	11805	383	66	24350	42	114	4157	74	17	406	61	1129	115	40	1483	141	18	37	547	17194	59	2906
# of potential edges	18177432	6642	68382	77006	858402	563250	14527532	708122	579882	809100	4078380	4921742	96383306	1410156	51302	337181406	255530	94556	20716152	429680	53592	631230	22052	1405410	1078482	131406	899652	351056	8372	31152	1037342	43606212	10920	3409562
Density	0.000584	0.002108	0.000936	0.000987	0.000437	0.002873	0.000170	0.001453	0.000805	0.000287	0.001065	0.000490	0.000122	0.000272	0.001286	0.000072	0.000164	0.001206	0.000201	0.000172	0.000317	0.000643	0.002766	0.000803	0.000107	0.000304	0.001648	0.000402	0.002150	0.001188	0.000527	0.000394	0.005403	0.000852
Max Degree	302	3	5	10	13	63	57	50	17	8	94	84	77	16	5	196	3	7	40	12	2	38	4	63	9	3	81	4	3	4	12	176	11	188
Mean Degree	2.490	0.171	0.244	0.273	0.405	2.154	0.649	1.222	0.613	0.258	2.150	1.088	1.202	0.322	0.291	1.326	0.083	0.370	0.913	0.113	0.073	0.511	0.409	0.952	0.111	0.110	1.563	0.238	0.196	0.209	0.537	2.604	0.562	1.573
Diameter	16	2	3	2	8	10	8	8	7	5	12	11	19	3	4	20	2	3	11	4	2	5	4	7	3	1	9	3	1	2	5	14	3	14
#Pairs with this distance	2	1	1	22	1	8	1	2	1	1	5	7	2	12	10	2	5	2	1	3	1	3	2	2	1	40	36	2	18	3	11	6	4	2

# of cited docs from all corpora	3255	58	107	175	291	566	2322	684	565	623	1483	1571	6211	636	122	10002	65	179	2462	147	14	393	80	946	205	163	581	343	73	76	391	4142	46	1024
% of cited docs from all corpora	76.3	70.7	40.8	62.9	31.4	75.4	60.9	81.2	74.1	69.2	73.4	70.8	63.3	53.5	53.7	54.5	12.8	58.1	54.1	22.4	6.0	49.4	53.7	79.8	19.7	44.9	61.2	57.8	79.3	42.9	38.4	62.7	43.8	55.4
# of effective edges	3255	58	107	175	291	566	2322	684	565	623	1483	1571	6211	636	122	10002	65	179	2462	147	14	393	80	946	205	163	581	343	73	76	391	4142	46	1024
# of potential edges	276955328	5326064	17017424	18056656	60210504	48778952	247597024	54689584	49493424	58456800	131203040	144128488	637698736	77162976	14744104	1192713576	32865712	20005216	295661504	42608512	15068864	51636840	9677848	77033072	67485128	23577576	61639448	38516536	5975584	11496504	66186088	428943008	6819960	119966344
Density	0.000012	0.000011	0.000006	0.000010	0.000005	0.000012	0.000009	0.000013	0.000011	0.000011	0.000011	0.000011	0.000010	0.000008	0.000008	0.000008	0.000002	0.000009	0.000008	0.000003	0.000001	0.000008	0.000008	0.000012	0.000003	0.000007	0.000009	0.000009	0.000012	0.000007	0.000006	0.000010	0.000007	0.000009
Max Degree	1505	52	28	279	85	1125	374	251	564	211	467	831	374	148	18	1027	13	199	304	43	2	470	158	831	40	16	106	249	43	20	29	568	358	277
Mean Degree	10.567	4.585	1.073	7.511	1.036	24.124	4.720	9.532	9.841	5.149	10.470	9.810	4.119	3.279	1.881	2.673	0.245	4.532	2.725	0.595	0.078	2.635	3.893	11.158	0.399	1.047	3.830	4.573	5.054	1.379	1.015	5.727	10.210	2.489
CITING/CITED PAPER CITATION NETWORK	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
#strongly connected components	4220	82	261	275	926	741	3794	758	761	897	1983	2193	9746	1178	226	18179	505	306	4456	652	232	794	149	1178	1038	362	884	591	92	177	1017	6540	105	1832
Size of the largest strongly connected component	3	1	2	2	2	5	3	19	2	2	19	3	5	3	2	7	2	2	4	2	1	2	1	3	2	2	16	2	1	1	2	6	1	3
% of docs in the largest strongly connected component	0.070	1.220	0.763	0.719	0.216	0.666	0.079	2.257	0.262	0.222	0.941	0.135	0.051	0.253	0.881	0.038	0.395	0.649	0.088	0.305	0.431	0.252	0.671	0.253	0.192	0.551	1.686	0.337	1.087	0.565	0.196	0.091	0.952	0.162
Average path length of the largest strongly connected component	1.167	0.000	1.000	1.000	1.000	1.600	1.333	2.298	1.000	1.000	2.298	1.333	1.450	1.167	1.000	1.857	1.000	1.000	1.667	1.000	0.000	1.000	0.000	1.333	1.000	1.000	2.421	1.000	0.000	0.000	1.000	1.733	0.000	1.333
Average path length of the strongly connected components of size>1	1.012	0.000	1.000	1.000	1.000	1.156	1.020	1.612	1.000	1.000	1.086	1.075	1.069	1.019	1.000	1.036	1.000	1.000	1.026	1.000	0.000	1.000	0.000	1.048	1.000	1.000	1.298	1.000	0.000	0.000	1.000	1.051	0.000	1.121
Weighted average path length of the strongly connected components of size>1	1.017	0.000	1.000	1.000	1.000	1.250	1.029	1.832	1.000	1.000	1.458	1.098	1.108	1.026	1.000	1.065	1.000	1.000	1.042	1.000	0.000	1.000	0.000	1.067	1.000	1.000	1.620	1.000	0.000	0.000	1.000	1.088	0.000	1.154
ABSENCE OF CITATION FOR AUTHORS (FOR THEIR PUBLICATIONS IN THE CORPUS)	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of authors never referenced	1150	66	172	196	763	149	1755	242	430	386	832	555	4400	1057	158	6635	606	316	2754	807	289	586	76	390	1099	329	666	609	60	192	605	2273	58	1191
% of authors never referenced	22.642	27.615	54.088	34.326	66.696	14.738	34.257	16.564	27.250	25.114	27.368	19.331	38.185	44.599	42.935	40.146	78.497	36.322	37.819	72.442	93.831	42.930	35.349	19.787	72.255	47.135	36.593	43.161	24.590	50.394	51.665	30.424	37.179	37.726
# of authors never referenced (aside self ref)	1156	66	180	196	779	168	1773	244	433	386	842	557	4528	1060	162	7049	615	323	2846	824	292	613	87	390	1133	340	695	611	60	197	640	2592	59	1258
% of authors never referenced (aside self ref)	22.760	27.615	56.604	34.326	68.094	16.617	34.609	16.701	27.440	25.114	27.697	19.401	39.295	44.726	44.022	42.651	79.663	37.126	39.083	73.968	94.805	44.908	40.465	19.787	74.490	48.711	38.187	43.303	24.590	51.706	54.654	34.694	37.821	39.848
ABSENCE OF CITATION FOR DOCUMENTS	acl	acmtslp	alta	anlp	cath	cl	coling	conll	csal	eacl	emnlp	hlt	icassps	ijcnlp	inlg	isca	jep	lre	lrec	ltc	modulad	mts	muc	naacl	paclic	ranlp	sem	speechc	tacl	tal	taln	taslp	tipster	trec	all	all without duplicates
# of docs never referenced	1009	24	155	103	636	185	1490	158	197	277	537	648	3607	552	105	8361	441	129	2090	509	218	402	69	240	834	200	368	250	19	101	628	2462	59	823
% of docs never referenced	23.663	29.268	59.160	37.050	68.608	24.634	39.087	18.765	25.853	30.778	26.584	29.202	36.739	46.465	46.256	45.532	87.154	41.883	45.914	77.591	93.966	50.566	46.309	20.236	80.269	55.096	38.778	42.159	20.652	57.062	61.629	37.280	56.190	44.559
# of docs never referenced (aside self ref)	1038	25	167	103	653	202	1529	164	202	281	561	663	3898	555	111	9851	455	133	2443	530	223	423	76	240	878	212	417	254	19	104	703	2875	60	976
% of docs never referenced (aside self ref)	24.343	30.488	63.740	37.050	70.442	26.897	40.110	19.477	26.509	31.222	27.772	29.878	39.703	46.717	48.899	53.646	89.921	43.182	53.669	80.793	96.121	53.208	51.007	20.236	84.504	58.402	43.941	42.833	20.652	58.757	68.989	43.534	57.143	52.842

Notes:
* A green column corpus has the same status, the only difference is that it seems more interesting.
* A doc is a paper published in a conference or a journal.
* For most situations, the notions of doc and paper are identical, but for a limited number of situations, the notions are different. For joint conferences, there are two docs and one paper.
* Productivity is defined as the # of papers divided by the # of authors.

total elapsed time (read and display included)= 11.481233333333334 minutes with 8 cores

computed on: Tue Sep 27 18:25:20 CEST 2016